Joe Santucci's Square Pizza Reviews
Joe Santucci's Square Pizza has an overall rating of 3.8 based on 37 reviews. Customer feedback on Joe Santucci's Square Pizza is mixed: Joe Santucci's Square Pizza reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious pizza, friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, generous portions, which strongly appeal to pizza lovers, families, casual diners, local residents. However, Joe Santucci's Square Pizza is often criticized for its long wait times, limited parking, higher prices, inconsistent service.
37 reviews
5 Stars
8
4 Stars
7
3 Stars
6
2 Stars
2
1 Star
1
How would you rate Joe Santucci's Square Pizza?
All Joe Santucci's Square Pizza Reviews (37)
alfonzorice3857
May 21, 2026
"Catering was alright, not great"
We ordered catering for a small party and it was just okay. The pizza showed up late and was kinda cold by the time we got it, plus we were missing plates which was annoying. The taste was fine, nothing terrible, but it defintely wasn’t worth the extra stress.
0
Reply
NathanHenry
May 03, 2026
"Feels pricier than it used to"
I ordered from Joe Santucci Square Pizza recently, and the food was alright overall. Nothing was bad, but I remember it feeling like a better deal before, and this time the price just stood out more than the pizza did.
The portions were decent, but once the fees and everything were added in, it felt a little high for a casual pizza night. I’d probably order again if I was really in the mood for it, but it’s not something I’d make a regular habit anymore.
The portions were decent, but once the fees and everything were added in, it felt a little high for a casual pizza night. I’d probably order again if I was really in the mood for it, but it’s not something I’d make a regular habit anymore.
0
Reply
TiaraPetty_65
April 30, 2026
"Good, but a little inconsistent"
Not gonna lie, the pizza can be really good sometimes, but it’s not always the same. Every now and then the crust feels a bit off or the sauce doesn’t taste quite right. Still enjoyable, just wish it was more consistent.
0
Reply
MarthaMintz_64
April 16, 2026
"Nice staff, but something about it felt slow"
The staff was nice and friendly enough, but something about it just felt a little slow overall. Not a bad experience, just not the quickest.
0
Reply
hello_brady405
April 13, 2026
"The pizza was okay, but nothing I’d..."
The pizza was okay, but nothing I’d rush back for. The crust was decent, and the food tasted fine overall, but it was a little bland for my taste. I also think the sauce could have had more flavor. Not bad, just not quite worth it compared to better pizza spots.
0
Reply
Victor-vanburen
April 02, 2026
"It got here faster than I thought it..."
It got here faster than I thought it would, like way quicker than... well, you know. The pizza was still hot too, so no complaints from me.
0
Reply
LoriHildreth_33
March 29, 2026
"So many good choices here"
The menu has a ton of options , so it was hard to pick just one thing . Definitely a good spot if you like having plenty of choices .
0
Reply
james1991
March 15, 2026
"Surprisingly clean and well-kept"
I was pleasantly surprised by how clean the place was. The tables were spotless too, which made the whole experience feel really comfortable.
0
Reply
philip-Mosley
March 14, 2026
"Pickup was kind of all over the place"
The pizza itself was fine, I guess, but picking it up was a bit frustrating. I’m not sure what was going on behind the counter, but it took longer than expected and the staff seemed confused about the orders.
0
Reply
JohnRoberts_66
March 06, 2026
"Nice crispy crust"
The crust was crisp on the bottom but still soft inside, which I really liked. It held up well without getting floppy. I’d definitely get it again, especially if I’m in the mood for a lighter crust.
0
Reply
KIM
February 26, 2026
"The wait was ridiculous"
I was excited to grab a pizza here, but the wait just dragged on way too long. It wasn’t even that busy, so after a while I was just sitting there wondering what was going on. The pizza itself was actually fine when it finally showed up. But then again, nope, I’m still annoyed. Waiting that long kind of killed the whole experience for me.
0
Reply
jonathanfussell1097
February 22, 2026
"We stopped by with the kids..."
We stopped by with the kids and they seemed to have a really good time. The whole place felt easy for families, which is always a relief. I kind of got the feeling they probably get a lot of families in there, because everything just seemed to work well for kids, though I’m only guessing
0
Reply
hello_robert746
February 22, 2026
"Pretty good pizza for the price..."
It was worth it... the pizza tasted good and the portions were fair for what you pay
0
Reply
gertrude2004
February 16, 2026
"Cozy little pizza spot, but I wanted clearer instructions"
It’s a nice, cozy pizza spot with a chill vibe inside. I liked the atmosphere and it felt easy to hang out there, but I did find myself wishing the instructions were a bit clearer, especially for ordering or knowing where to go. Overall, still a pleasant place to grab pizza...
0
Reply
hello_rita215
February 11, 2026
"You can usually tell quickly when..."
You can usually tell quickly when an online pizza order was rushed, but this one wasn’t. Everything was exactly how I asked for it, no missing toppings, no weird mix-ups, nothing off. Reading between the lines, someone actually paid attention to the order, and I really appreciated that. Super happy with it.
0
Reply
hello_irene946
February 07, 2026
"I liked the specialty pizzas here..."
I liked the specialty pizzas here, they were actually good. just kinda wish there were a few More options to choose from.
0
Reply
jamesperrier8782
February 01, 2026
"Decent pizza, but I expected a little more"
The pizza itself tasted good, so I can’t really complain about the flavor. I just feel like for what I paid, the portions should’ve been a bit bigger. Maybe I was extra hungry, but I still think it’s fair to expect to feel full after ordering pizza. It wasn’t bad at all, and I’d probably order again, just not if I’m really hungry or looking for a bigger meal.
0
Reply
nicholas_Sanchez99
February 01, 2026
"Friendly staff and worth the price"
The staff was really nice and easy to deal with. They helped me with my order quickly and didn’t make it feel like a hassle at all. I’m careful about what I spend, but the service made it feel worth it.
0
Reply
hello_clifton874
January 27, 2026
"I ordered from Joe Santucci’s and the..."
I ordered from Joe Santucci’s and the pizza got here warm, which I was happy about.
It was not piping hot like it had just come out of the oven, but it was warm enough that the cheese was still soft and the crust tasted good. The fries did cool down a bit faster though.
Overall, it was a solid order. I would give it 4 stars because the temperature was good, just not totally perfect.
It was not piping hot like it had just come out of the oven, but it was warm enough that the cheese was still soft and the crust tasted good. The fries did cool down a bit faster though.
Overall, it was a solid order. I would give it 4 stars because the temperature was good, just not totally perfect.
0
Reply
JoanSaddler
January 16, 2026
"My gut says this is a really solid square pizza"
I had a good feeling about this pizza as soon as I saw those crispy edges, it lived up to it. The sauce was really tasty, the cheese wasn’t too heavy, and the crust had that perfect crunch while still being soft inside. My only small gripe is that I wish mine had a bit more toppings. Still, just going off my gut, this is the kind of pizza I’d definitely order again.
0
Reply
Have a question about Joe Santucci's Square Pizza?
Log in to ask your Joe Santucci's Square Pizza question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
